Skip to content

La Rainette

L'actu de la Rainette

Private Rentals: Is 123 SeLoger Really More Cost-Effective Than a Real Estate Agency?

In France, renting out a property directly between private individuals accounts for a growing share of the rental market. Platforms like 123 Loger offer…

Propriétaire particulier comparant les offres de location sur une plateforme immobilière en ligne depuis son bureau à domicile
5 min

In France, private landlords are accounting for a growing share of the rental market. Platforms such as 123 Loger connect landlords directly with prospective tenants, without going through a real estate agency.

The actual cost-effectiveness of this type of service compared with appointing a professional cannot be reduced to the difference in advertised prices. It also depends on the services provided, the time involved and the responsibilities assumed, all of which vary depending on the option chosen.

The total cost of renting out a property: what the bill really covers

Comparing the price of a listing on 123 Loger with that of a real estate agency means looking beyond the initial amount. The law regulates the fees that can be charged to tenants and landlords: only certain services (viewings, preparing the application file, drafting the lease and the move-in inspection) can be shared, subject to regulatory caps based on floor area.

These caps are maximums, not fixed rates. For the services concerned, the tenant’s share cannot exceed the landlord’s. Many landlords overlook this point when comparing the two options.

Landlords who use a private rental platform save on brokerage and negotiation fees, which they would have to pay under a traditional agency agreement.

Looking at reviews of 123 SeLoger for rentals, feedback appears to focus more on service quality than on numerical comparisons with agencies. The Trustpilot score is not a measure of cost-effectiveness, and no public data currently makes it possible to establish the full cost of the 123 Loger service or the precise list of included services and additional charges.

Real estate agent outside a city agency, illustrating the comparison between a traditional agency and renting directly from a landlord

Time spent by the landlord: the hidden cost of renting directly

Cost-effectiveness is not measured in euros alone. Landlords who manage the rental themselves take on a range of tasks, the workload for which depends on the local market and the number of applications received.

  • Writing and posting the listing, screening applications, and arranging and conducting viewings: in some high-demand cities, a single listing can attract dozens of applications, adding up to several hours of work.
  • Checking the tenant’s application documents, requesting guarantees and assessing their ability to pay: these steps require a basic understanding of the regulations to avoid discrimination or requests for prohibited documents.
  • Drafting a compliant lease, carrying out the move-in inspection and handing over the keys: any mistake or omission in these documents can have legal consequences in the event of a later dispute.

The landlord’s time replaces the cost of the agency, but that time is not always estimated in advance. An employed landlord who spends around twenty hours arranging a rental could find the savings less significant when weighed against their hourly rate.

What 123 Loger handles—and what is left to do

The information available online does not make it possible to determine precisely whether 123 Loger only connects landlords and tenants or also handles some of the administrative steps. Yet this distinction is crucial.

A platform that simply posts a listing does not provide the same service as an agency that drafts the lease, checks applications and carries out the move-in inspection. Comparing prices without comparing services distorts the cost-effectiveness calculation.

Property management after the lease is signed: the overlooked cost in the comparison

Most comparisons between renting directly and using an agency stop once the lease is signed. Ongoing property management (rent receipts, chasing arrears, handling repairs and reconciling service charges) is a separate cost, often charged by agencies offering a management agreement as a percentage of the monthly rent.

Landlords who choose 123 Loger to find a tenant will need to manage the property themselves or sign a separate management agreement with a professional. The upfront savings can be offset by the cost of ongoing management if the landlord is unable to handle it themselves.

Conversely, an experienced landlord with enough time and a good understanding of the legal framework can make a net gain from renting directly, provided the property is in a market with low vacancy rates.

Couple viewing an apartment for rent directly from a landlord, checking a listing on a smartphone during a property viewing

Renting directly from a landlord or using a real estate agency: what tips the balance

Rather than choosing one option outright, the right choice depends on factors specific to each situation.

  • The local market: in a high-demand area, finding a tenant takes little time, making it less worthwhile to delegate the search. In a less sought-after area, an agency’s network can speed up the rental process and reduce vacancy.
  • Number of properties: landlords with several units have more reason to delegate than those with just one apartment.
  • Legal knowledge: rental regulations change regularly (rent controls, mandatory inspections and lease requirements). A mistake can cost more than the agency fees saved.
  • Personal availability: managing a rental takes time at every stage, not just when the property is first put on the market.

What online reviews don’t measure

Online reviews generally focus on responsiveness, listing quality or the number of enquiries received. These are useful criteria, but not enough to establish the financial picture.

No public source currently provides a verified comparison of the total cost of renting out a property through 123 Loger versus using an agency for equivalent services. Landlords who want to make this calculation will need to list the services they require, estimate how much time they can devote to the process, and compare that with quotes from local agencies that itemise their fees.

The true cost-effectiveness calculation is not based on a single expense, but on the entire rental cycle, from publishing the listing to managing the lease day to day.

Private Rentals: Is 123 SeLoger Really More Cost-Effective Than a Real Estate Agency?